What a Roofer's Report for an Insurance Claim Must Contain
What a Roofer's Report for an Insurance Claim Must Contain
Your insurer has looked at your roof claim and come back with "wear and tear". Or it has not come out to look at all. Either way, what decides the outcome is a piece of paper from your roofer, and almost nobody tells you what should be on it.
There is a reason for that silence. We went looking for a published standard covering what a roofer's report for an insurance claim must contain, and there is not one: not from the NFRC, RICS, the ABI or the British Standards Institution. The NFRC's own advice on arranging a roof survey is about working safely at height, not what the resulting document should say. So the answer has to come from the decisions the Financial Ombudsman Service publishes, where you can read which reports persuaded an ombudsman and which lost the claim for the homeowner who paid.
At a Glance: What a Written Roof Report Costs in 2026
| What you are buying | Typical UK price | Source and date |
|---|---|---|
| Basic visual inspection, no detailed report | £100 to £200 | MyJobQuote, 12 October 2026 |
| Roof inspection, average | £250 to £260 | MyJobQuote 22 Sept 2026; Checkatrade Sept 2026 |
| Full written roof survey and report | £250 to £400 | MyJobQuote, 12 October 2026 |
| Roof survey, average £375 | £300 to £500 | Checkatrade, September 2026 |
| Report specifically for an insurance claim | £250 to £500 | MyJobQuote, 22 September 2026 |
| Structural engineer's report, if the structure is in question | £500 to £1,500 and up | MyJobQuote, 22 September 2026 |
Those guides do not agree and we are not going to pretend they do. MyBuilder puts a standard inspection at about £150, Checkatrade says £260, and MyJobQuote's own two pages, twenty days apart, say £250 and around £300. The honest range for a written report is £250 to £500, and the cheapest end buys a visit rather than a document.
What Makes a Report Persuasive, and What Sinks One
The Financial Ombudsman Service publishes guidance for insurers on how it handles storm damage complaints, and its most useful line is about photographs:
"Sometimes we see reports where the roof hasn't been inspected properly and the insurer has relied on an aerial photo. Unless the photo clearly shows deterioration, and this is explained in the report, then we may not be persuaded that you've shown the exclusion fairly applies."
Read that from your side of the table. A photograph proves nothing on its own unless the report explains what it shows, and the same test applies to your roofer's photographs. A folder of blurry images taken from the lawn is not evidence. A close photograph of one failed component, with a sentence saying what it shows and why that matters, is.
In a published case study comparing an insurer's evidence with a homeowner's, the service said: "After looking at both reports, we thought that the second report had more detail and authority, and was therefore more persuasive." Detail and authority. That is the specification.
What the Report Has to Do, Point by Point
Pulled together from the ombudsman decisions we read, a report that works does six things.
It records that the roofer physically went onto or into the roof, and says how, because the alternative is guesswork from the ground. It names the component and the mechanism rather than the weather: "storm damage to roof" is an opinion, while "the flashing to the skew had been lifted by wind and was no longer sealed, and this is the path the water took" is a finding. It explains the reasoning and not only the conclusion, which is what the ombudsman means by reports that "explain the expert's thinking".
It says what the condition was before the event, where the roofer honestly can. In one decision the roofer had inspected the same roof two months earlier and could state the flashing was then sound, and that fact did more work than everything else in the file.
It carries photographs close enough to read, each tied to a statement in the text. And it separates the condition report from the repair quote, because several decisions turn on insurers treating a price for the work as evidence about the cause.
The Sentence That Loses the Claim
Here is the failure mode nobody warns homeowners about.
In a 2024 decision involving a chimney, the homeowner's own roofer described the mortar as distressed, noted several cracks, and said the plaster had lost its adhesion, then concluded that the water ingress was almost certainly the result of the storm. The ombudsman did not uphold the claim, and said why:
"The roofer's comments support this point with reference to a loss of adhesion, cracking, and distressed mortar. I think what the roofer says about the storm causing water ingress is true. But the storm wasn't the underlying cause of the damage. It merely highlighted a pre-existing issue."
The roofer was being professionally honest and he destroyed the claim doing it. The lesson is not that deterioration should be hidden, because a report that conceals what is obviously there will be torn apart the moment the insurer sends anyone out. It is that condition has to be addressed deliberately rather than mentioned in passing: the report needs to say whether the ageing caused the failure or merely sat alongside it. A roofer who writes "the mortar is weathered consistent with its age, but the specific failure here is wind uplift to the flashing, which was sound when I inspected in September" has handled the same facts without handing the insurer its defence.
The flip side is that the insurer's report is judged by the same standard. In another decision from the same period the ombudsman dismissed a surveyor's findings outright: "I'd also expect the surveyor to have highlighted the cracking and taken illustrative photos to support his view that there was pre-existing damage. As discussed earlier, I don't find his report persuasive." So ask for a copy of whatever report the insurer relied on. Ombudsmen have been plain that insurers should share findings material to the decision so you can challenge them, and it is worth knowing what the Ombudsman actually decides on a refused storm claim first.
Commissioning It, Paying for It, and Getting It Back
Commission the report yourself and pay for it yourself. A report written as a favour inside a quote is worth very little; one you have instructed and paid for is a professional opinion. If you have not started the claim yet, the full storm damage claim process from first call to settlement sets out the order of events.
Timing matters more than people realise. The Financial Conduct Authority reviewed claims handling across fifteen home insurers in a report published on 22 July 2025, and found this about inspections:
"the firm didn't carry out an inspection of the damage unless the decision to reject the claim was questioned or if the claim exceeded a certain amount."
Nobody is coming to look at your roof unless you push back or the claim is big. The same review found that of 118,890 storm claims in 2024, only 32% of customers who got in touch received a settlement payment, 49% were rejected, and 19% simply did not continue with the claim. A report is how you stop being part of that 19%.
Can You Get the Cost Back?
Sometimes. There is no general rule, and the ombudsman says as much: "We don't often award costs but we will think about what's fair in each individual case."
The decisions that do award it turn on one question: whether the report changed the outcome. In a February 2025 decision an ombudsman put it like this:
"It's long been the approach of this service that where an insured incurs a cost which changes the course of a claim (or complaint), that they should not be left out of pocket for that charge."
That homeowner got her £240 report cost back with interest. In a July 2025 decision a £558 surveyor's report was reimbursed at 25%, having influenced only part of the outcome. In two others the cost was refused flatly, because the insurer had already appointed its own surveyor and the policy covered professional fees for rebuilding but expressly not for preparing a claim.
So: you pay up front, and you have a decent argument for getting it back if the report changed the insurer's mind, or if the insurer's own conduct made it necessary, by delay, by never sending anyone, or by inviting you to challenge the decline with evidence. Check your policy for a claims preparation clause, which some include and most people never notice. And keep the receipt: one homeowner lost a claim for £1,294 of scaffolding and report costs for want of paperwork.
The Roofer Who Offers to Run the Claim for You
Be careful with this one. Under the FCA's perimeter guidance, a roofer who merely supplies information in support of your claim is not carrying on a regulated activity. But the FCA gives, as an example of something that probably is, notifying a claim and then providing evidence for it, or helping negotiate the settlement on the policyholder's behalf. A roofing firm offering to handle the whole claim for a cut of the settlement is in territory that needs FCA authorisation, so check it on the Financial Services Register first. Writing you a report is a roofing job. Running your claim is a financial services job. Who pays for what on a roof insurance claim covers who is who when someone does turn up.
Regional Price Differences
There is no regionalised price list anywhere for a roof report. We looked. MyJobQuote's roof survey page of 12 October 2026 says only that London and the South East tend to cost more, with no figures attached, and Checkatrade's September 2026 inspection page gives no regional breakdown at all.
What does vary, and what a report is really priced on, is the roofer's time. MyBuilder's roofer price guide, updated 21 August 2026, puts hourly rates at £40 to £60 in London, £30 to £50 in the South East, £25 to £40 across the Midlands and Scotland, and £20 to £35 in the North of England, with day rates of £280 to £360. A report is usually half a day on site plus the write up, so the same document can reasonably cost half as much again in London as in Yorkshire. Where an engineer is needed rather than a roofer the geography bites harder: MyJobQuote's guide of 22 September 2026 gives £90 to £150 an hour in London and the South East against £60 to £100 in rural areas.
For what a full survey costs with no claim involved, see what a full roof survey costs in 2026, and before anyone goes up a ladder, photograph the damage from the ground before anything is touched.
Need a roofer who can write a proper report, not just a quote? Search localroofer.directory to find roofing contractors in your area. Ask for a written condition report with dated photographs, priced separately from any repair quote, and say up front that it is for an insurance claim.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will my insurer accept a report from any roofer?
There is no accreditation requirement, because there is no published standard for these reports. What an insurer and an ombudsman weigh is the content: whether the roof was inspected, whether the failure mechanism is identified, whether the photographs show what the text claims, and whether the reasoning holds together. A detailed report from a local roofer beats a thin one from a large firm, and a roofer who can say what they are qualified in gives it more standing still.
Should I get the report before or after the insurer decides?
Before, if you can afford to. The FCA found that many firms do not inspect unless the rejection is questioned, so arriving with evidence at the first notification changes how the claim is handled rather than how an appeal goes. If it has already been declined, get one anyway: a report that changes the decision is also the one you have the best chance of recovering the cost of.
What if my roofer has already done the repair?
This happens constantly and it is survivable, but harder. Ask the roofer to write up what they found before they fixed it, with whatever photographs they took, and be honest about the sequence. Ombudsmen have criticised insurers for not simply telephoning the repairer to ask what they saw. You cannot reconstruct evidence after the fact, so be clear about what was observed and when.
Can I use a drone survey or a thermal scan instead?
They are useful additions and poor substitutes. The ombudsman's criticism of aerial imagery is that it rarely shows deterioration clearly enough to prove anything on its own, and that applies to your drone shots as much as to the insurer's satellite view. A thermal scan is good evidence of where water is now and weak evidence of how it got there. Use either to support a report based on a physical inspection, not to replace one.
Peter Balmfort
Expert roofing advice for UK homeowners.
Related Articles
How You Report a Storm Damage Claim Changes What Happens Next
12 November 2026
The Government's Trusted Trader Scheme: Where It Actually Stands
29 October 2026