How You Report a Storm Damage Claim Changes What Happens Next
How You Report a Storm Damage Claim Changes What Happens Next
Your roof loses tiles overnight. By breakfast you are either on the phone to your insurer or typing into a web form, and most people assume it makes no difference which.
The Financial Conduct Authority's review of home claims handling suggests otherwise. At one firm, it found, the way a claim arrived changed how hard it was investigated and how it ended. That is one firm in one year, not a rule about the whole market. But it is the regulator saying out loud that the first fifteen minutes of a claim are not neutral, and the rules say they are not allowed to be.
At a Glance: The Numbers Behind Storm Claims
| Figure | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Storm claims at the sampled firms, 2024 | 118,890 | FCA review, 22 July 2025 |
| Received a settlement payment | 32% | FCA review, 22 July 2025 |
| Rejected | 49% | FCA review, 22 July 2025 |
| Customers who did not continue the claim | 19% | FCA review, 22 July 2025 |
| Buildings only claims acceptance rate, 2025 | 62.44% | FCA value measures, 21 July 2026 |
| Average buildings only payout, 2025 | £9,036.84 | FCA value measures, 21 July 2026 |
| Buildings complaints to the Ombudsman, Apr to Jun 2026 | 1,766, 33% upheld | FOS, 22 July 2026 |
The walkaway figure is the one nobody quotes. Roughly a fifth of people who contacted their insurer about storm damage simply stopped. They are not in the rejection statistics, and whatever happened to their roofs did not get paid for either.
What the Regulator Found About How Claims Arrive
The FCA published "Home and travel claims handling arrangements" on 22 July 2025, covering 15 home insurers and 8 travel insurers. The storm section is blunt. Across those firms in 2024, of 118,890 claims classified as storm damage, 32% resulted in a payment and 49% were rejected. Five firms had an acceptance rate below 30%. The reasons given for rejection were damage attributed to wear and tear rather than the storm, damage below the excess, and weather that did not meet the insurer's definition of a storm.
Then this, which is the finding that matters here:
"In 1 firm, customers appeared to receive inconsistent outcomes based on how the claim was notified. For example, we saw telephony notifications more often resulted in more in-depth investigations, including an inspection of the damage, but electronic claim notifications more often resulted in the claim being rejected."
Read it carefully. It is one firm. It is not evidence that phoning gets you paid across the industry, and anyone telling you that is overstating a regulator's observation. What it does show is that two customers with the same damage and the same policy could be treated differently because of the channel they used.
A second finding in the same review is arguably worse and has gone almost unreported. Firms checked wind speed using weather apps and local data, and in some cases relied on that "without considering contributory factors", including whether a property sits in an isolated location, or "where the firm didn't carry out an inspection of the damage unless the decision to reject the claim was questioned or if the claim exceeded a certain amount". In other words, at some firms nobody looks at your roof unless you push back or the figure is big enough.
Why the rules say this should not happen
Three parts of the FCA Handbook bite on this. The oldest is ICOBS 8.1.1R, which requires an insurer to handle claims promptly and fairly, give reasonable guidance to help a policyholder make a claim, and not unreasonably reject one.
The Consumer Duty goes further. PRIN 2A.6.1R applies the consumer support outcome "regardless of the channel used or intended to be used when interacting with, or providing support to, retail customers". PRIN 2A.6.2R requires firms to make sure customers do not face unreasonable barriers when they want to submit a claim, and the guidance at 2A.6.3G defines those barriers to include steps that are unreasonably onerous, complex or hard to understand.
Then the monitoring rule, PRIN 2A.9.10R, which requires a firm to identify "whether for any product the firm manufactures or distributes, any group of retail customers is experiencing different outcomes compared to another group of retail customers of the same product", with 2A.9.12R obliging it to act where it finds one.
Put those together and a channel that quietly produces more rejections is not an operational quirk. It is a group of customers getting worse outcomes on the same product, which the firm is required to spot and fix.
What the channels actually look like in 2026
Checked in October 2026, the market now routes storm claims to self service first, and the wording varies more than you would expect.
Aviva's storm damage page steers hard online, saying the fastest route is to log into MyAviva, that it may give an instant decision, and there is "no need to call us". Direct Line and Churchill both accept home claims online but add a specific instruction that claims relating to a roof on a buildings policy should be registered with Home Claims. NFU Mutual asks customers to use its weather claim web form to avoid telephone queues, but gates the form on the claim not requiring urgent action. esure states the opposite of the FCA's finding outright: "Whether you tell us over the phone or online, we follow the same steps."
Ageas carries the single most important sentence any insurer publishes on this:
"Unless it is an emergency, please do not carry out any repairs or replace items without us agreeing to this first. If you need to take action to protect your property, we recommend that you do so only if the temporary repairs can be easily removed for a full inspection. The cost of any temporary repairs will not be reimbursed if your claim is declined following our inspection."
Worth knowing too that the 24 hour helpline many people expect is often not the buildings claims line. esure's claims number runs Monday to Friday 8am to 8pm and Saturday 9am to 4pm, NFU Mutual's claims department 8am to 6pm, Tesco Underwriting's 8am to 6pm on weekdays. The round the clock numbers usually belong to Home Emergency, an optional extra rather than standard buildings cover.
A form also flattens things a phone call does not. NFU Mutual's web form asks you to grade the damage on a fixed three point scale, "not very extensive", "quite extensive" or "very extensive", asks whether the property is secure and habitable, and does not ask for photographs at all. A handler, by contrast, can check the weather data live while you are on the line, which is exactly what happened in the case below.
What To Do in the First 48 Hours
Two Ombudsman decisions, taken together, show where claims are actually won and lost. Neither carries an issue date, because Ombudsman decisions do not; the only date in them is the deadline for accepting or rejecting.
In DRN-4942346 against Advantage Insurance, upheld with a decision deadline of 29 August 2024, a felt roof was torn off in December 2023 and the homeowner had an emergency repair done at £400 before the insurer validated anything. The insurer declined. The Ombudsman listened to the notification call, found the handler had checked the weather on the call, confirmed 58mph gusts, asked for photos and said "That's fine, no problem at all" when told there were none. His conclusion:
"I think the call handler should have told Mrs M during the call that Advantage needed to assess and accept the claim first, and that any repairs done before this would be at her own risk."
The claim was ordered to be settled. In DRN-5126950 against Lloyds Bank General Insurance, not upheld, decision deadline 5 January 2025, the mirror image happened. Damage reported in January 2024, a £13,800 estimate triggered a surveyor visit in February, and by then the entire roof had been replaced. The Ombudsman accepted a storm had occurred, and still found the roof's condition was the dominant cause, relying partly on photographs.
Same act, opposite outcomes. The difference was what the insurer said at notification and what the photographs showed.
The practical checklist
Photograph everything before you touch it, from the ground and from the loft, and keep the originals with their timestamps. In DRN-4237783 an insurer's surveyor argued the claim could not be substantiated because "the policyholder does not have any photographic evidence of the damage at the time of the loss". That homeowner won anyway, but it is not a position you want to be in.
Make safe only in a way that can be undone. That is Ageas's own test and it is a good one whoever you are insured with. A tarpaulin lifts off for an inspection; a new roof does not.
Get the approval position in writing. Ask directly whether the insurer needs to inspect before any repair, and whether a temporary repair is covered if the claim is later declined. If you are told on the phone, email a one line summary back the same day. DRN-4942346 turned on precisely this, and the insurer's own file note was found not to be an accurate record of the call.
Do not chase the weather data yourself. The Ombudsman obtains it, from providers it names as EuroTempest and WeatherNet, and it will look further back in the records if you were away when the damage happened. A Met Office named storm helps but is not proof on its own.
If the form will not let you describe what actually happened, phone instead, then write down who you spoke to and what they said.
Storm damaged roof and no idea who to call? Find vetted local roofers who can make safe and provide the written report your insurer will ask for at localroofer.directory.
Regional Price Differences and What You Risk Up Front
The money at stake in the first 48 hours is your own. Until the insurer accepts the claim, every pound you spend making the roof safe is at risk, which is what Ageas's warning spells out.
On MyJobQuote's figures, last updated 17 September 2026, an emergency call out adds £100 to £300 on top of normal prices, and temporary weatherproofing costs £100 to £300 depending on access. An emergency roof inspection runs £250 to £450 on its 12 October 2026 survey guide, against £100 to £200 for a basic visual inspection booked normally and £250 to £400 for a full survey. Roofers charge £35 to £45 an hour or £280 to £360 a day.
Regionally, MyJobQuote puts London and the South East at 20% to 30% above the North for the same emergency work. Scaffolding, if the make safe needs it, is £300 to £800 for a house on the same guide, while MyBuilder's 21 August 2026 page gives £600 to £1,000 for one side of a two storey semi over four to six weeks. Those two guides do not agree, and MyBuilder flags its own figures as inconsistent, so take the range rather than a single number.
Set against that risk, buildings only cover accepted 62.44% of claims in 2025, against 70.94% for buildings and contents combined and 71.06% for contents only, the worst of the three on both acceptance and complaints. The FCA cautions that firms report home claims acceptance inconsistently.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I phone or claim online after storm damage?
There is no safe general answer. The FCA found a channel difference at one firm in 2024, and esure states its two channels follow identical steps. The practical test is whether you can tell the full story. If the damage is complicated, the property is insecure, or you need to make safe immediately, phone, because a handler can take detail a drop down list cannot and you get a record of what you were told.
Will my insurer pay for a tarpaulin before the claim is accepted?
Not necessarily. Ageas states plainly that temporary repair costs will not be reimbursed if the claim is declined after inspection, and no insurer page we could read promises to authorise emergency repairs by phone. Make safe if the property is at risk, keep it removable, keep the receipt, and ask in writing whether it is covered.
Do I have to supply photographs when I report the claim?
No insurer form we checked requires them at the point of notification, and NFU Mutual's does not ask for photographs at all. The real deadline is not the form, it is the moment the damage is altered. Once a roof is repaired or replaced, the pre repair evidence cannot be recreated, which is what sank the claim in DRN-5126950.
How long do I have to report storm damage?
Policies normally require notification as soon as reasonably practical, and some insurers argue that condition is a precondition of cover. Aviva says it has no time limit but encourages prompt reporting. In DRN-5768842 an Ombudsman declined to let an insurer rely on late notification to refuse a claim, so lateness is not automatically fatal, but there is no reason to test it.
Jenna Bathurst
Expert roofing advice for UK homeowners.
Related Articles
What a Roofer's Report for an Insurance Claim Must Contain
17 November 2026
The Government's Trusted Trader Scheme: Where It Actually Stands
29 October 2026